0
Vincent Teo Posted 19 years ago
Grammar

alone

Can I say,


  

Top answer

Hi, I am not sure whether it is correct to say "go out for a wedding dinner", though going out for a beer is correct... I'd like to point a tense mistake that you've made. If you say the guy was alone, then his parents must have left the house earlier, so I think the Past Perfect tense works better: «He was alone in the house.

  • Hi, I am not sure whether it is correct to say "go out for a wedding dinner", though going out for a beer is correct...
  • I'd like to point a tense mistake that you've made.
  • If you say the guy was alone, then his parents must have left the house earlier, so I think the Past Perfect tense works better: «He was alone in the house.
  • »
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

9 Answers
0
Hi, I am not sure whether it is correct to say "go out for a wedding dinner", though going out for a beer is correct...

I'd like to point a tense mistake that you've made. If you say the guy was alone, then his parents must have left the house earlier, so I think the Past Perfect tense works better:

«He was alone in the house. His parents had gone to a wedding dinner.»
0
(a) He was alone at home. His parents went out for a wedding dinner.

(b) He was alone in the house. His parents attended for / to a wedding dinner. I only know attend to.

(c) He alone stayed at home alone.
0
Doll: Isn't "attend" transitive in that meaning? And anyway, saying someone attended/ has attended a wedding dinner won't mean he was/is still there at the moment of speech.

IMHO, "attend" won't fit in Vincent's example.

P.S.: Expecting you to tell me where my fault is...
0
Hmm, you are right Ant. I think he should say just attend, not attend to. But I am afraid I don't agree with you about the meaning of attend. If you look up its meaing, you will see this: to be present at.

As for go out,went out for diner or went out to dinner are both possible to me.But you know, I am not a native speaker.
0
Doll: «But I am afraid I don't agree with you about the meaning of attend. If you look up its meaing, you will see this: to be present at.»

Yeah, and this is what happens:

1. He was alone in the house. His parents had gone to a wedding dinner.

2. He was alone in the house. His parents were at a wedding dinner.

I believe both #1 and #2 are OK. Then, here's the
0
Okay, let's wait for a native speaker to clear the situation. Emotion: smile
0
I think that Ant is correct on this.
0
Vincent Teo
(a) He was at home alone. His parents went out for to a wedding dinner/a wedding reception.

(b) He was alone in the house. His parents were attending attended for / to a wedding dinner/a wedding reception.

Related Questions