0
Anonymous Posted 9 years ago
Grammar

Active Passive voice

Two sentences with intransitive verbs (i think) n prep phrase, yet one can be changed into a passive n other cant. Why ? Can someone please explain.

He is sleeping in a hotel.

............

He is talking to a stranger.

A strange is being talked to by him.

  

Top answer

" You do get credit for saying "please," though! I suppose you could say "The hotel is being slept in by him," but I can't imagine anyone actually saying it in real life. "A stranger is being talked to by him" is equally unnatural.

  • " You do get credit for saying "please," though!
  • I suppose you could say "The hotel is being slept in by him," but I can't imagine anyone actually saying it in real life.
  • "A stranger is being talked to by him" is equally unnatural.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0

If you're asking volunteers to take time to reply to your post, please capitalize "I" and take the time to spell out even the long, difficult words like "and."

You do get credit for saying "please," though!

I suppose you could say "The hotel is being slept in by him," but I can't imagine anyone actually saying it in real life. "A stranger is being talked to by him" is equally unna

0

Although it is clumsy and not to be recommended, I feel that "A stranger is being talked to by him" works slightly better than "A hotel is being slept in by him", which is very odd. My suggestion for why it is so odd is that the hotel is not affected in any way by someone sleeping in it. Other people may have other ideas.

0

If you consider the preposition as the particle of a phrasal verb, then both verbs have an object -- him and hotel. (The hotel is being slept in. The stranger is being talked to.)

When an active-voice sentence has the construct "subject+verb+object" then technically it can be changed to passive voice. But that does not mean the resulting sentence will be anything that wo

Related Questions