0
Nikoo Posted 14 years ago
Essay & Composition Writing

Accuracy of editors' opinion

I asked a non-native editor to work on my 260-page text and after around 5 hours he replied my email, saying that the text is full of errors. His comments are general and do not contain any specific point.  
Several people had evaluated my paper before and said that the whole structure is quite good. 

Do you have any experience of working with editors?  

Should I change the whole structure of my writing?
  

Top answer

Nikoo I asked a non-native editor to work on my 260-page text and after around 5 hours he replied my email, saying that the text is full of errors. His comments are general and do not contain any specific point. Several people had evaluated my paper before and said that the whole structure is quite good.

  • Nikoo I asked a non-native editor to work on my 260-page text and after around 5 hours he replied my email, saying that the text is full of errors.
  • His comments are general and do not contain any specific point.
  • Several people had evaluated my paper before and said that the whole structure is quite good.
  • He doesn't sound very helpful.
  • If he can't give specifics, and/or correct your text, I wonder what value he has at all.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
NikooI asked a non-native editor to work on my 260-page text and after around 5 hours he replied my email, saying that the text is full of errors. His comments are general and do not contain any specific point. Several people had evaluated my paper before and said that the whole structure is quite good.
He doesn't sound very helpful. If he can't give specif
0
Oh... Kris
Thank you so much.
I don't know what to say.
I'ts very kind of you.

I selected three parts. Is that OK?

Dear Kris the link to your contact info is not active.

Unfortunately, I couldn't find your email address
0
Sorry about that. I've updated my profile to show my email address.
Yes three parts is fine, but you can send the whole thing if you like.
0
Thank you so much for your help.

I sent the file.

Related Questions