0
Zongtang Posted 16 years ago
Grammar

About comparison

In this term , we use a new text book. In the book, teachers find a rule whih is not line with it used to be. The original sentence in textbook is as follows. "This pen is three times as long as that one. or we can say: This pen is three times longer than that one. but in the past, techer often explained this rule like this This pen is three times as long as that one. or we can say: This pen is twice longer than that one. We can find that in the text the sentence -This pen is three times as long as that one, is equal to this pen is three times longer than that one. Do they have the same meaning? Is the rule right in the past or right at prsent textbook?. I'm looking forward to your earliest reply.
  

Top answer

Good question, zongtang. There's a difference of opinion on this. I continue to hold the opinion that "X times longer than Y" makes no sense and should not be used.

  • Good question, zongtang.
  • There's a difference of opinion on this.
  • I continue to hold the opinion that "X times longer than Y" makes no sense and should not be used.
  • But most of our vetran members consider it natural and correct.
  • The situation you describe with the updated text book seems to carry this to a new level of absurdity.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
Good question, zongtang. There's a difference of opinion on this.

I continue to hold the opinion that "X times longer than Y" makes no sense and should not be used.
But most of our vetran members consider it natural and correct.

The situation you describe with the updated text book seems to carry this to a new level of absurdity.

I can't give an opinion on whether

Related Questions