0
Vincent Teo Posted 17 years ago
Grammar

About comma 2

Can I say,

(a) One morning when Miss Lim was out of the classroom, the pupils were going to make noise. (without comma)

(
b) One morning, when Miss Lim was out, the pupils were going to make noise.
(with comma)

(c) One morning, when Miss Lim was out and the pupils were going to make noise.
(with comma)
  

Top answer

Hi, Can I say, 'To make noise' is not idiomatic. Say 'to be noisy'. (a) One morning when Miss Lim was out of the classroom, the pupils were going to make noise.

  • Hi, Can I say, 'To make noise' is not idiomatic.
  • Say 'to be noisy'.
  • (a) One morning when Miss Lim was out of the classroom, the pupils were going to make noise.
  • (without comma) (b) One morning, when Miss Lim was out, the pupils were going to make noise.
  • (with comma) (c) One morning, when Miss Lim was out and the pupils were going to make noise.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
Hi,
Can I say,

'To make noise' is not idiomatic. Say 'to be noisy'.

(a) One morning when Miss Lim was out of the classroom, the pupils were going to make noise. (without comma)

(b) One morning, when Miss Lim was out, the pupils were going to make noise.
(with comma)

(c) One morning, when Miss Lim was out and the pupils were going to make noise.

Related Questions