0
Anonymous Posted 18 years ago
Grammar
a quote as a noun equivalent
Hi,
I think my reasoning is faulted. Can you tell me why it is so.
A general goal would be, "Get in shape." But a specific goal would say, "Join a health club and work out 3 days a week."
I have difficulty understanding the correctness of the placements of commas for the sentences like the ones above. I happen to think those in quotes are like a noun or its equivalent and see no valid reason to have commas as they did.
A general goal would be this. But a specific goal would say this.
I think my reasoning is not sound (or faulted) in that it seems a known practice to write like this (with a comma before a quote):
John would say, "He would delivered the pizza as soon as possible."
I think my reasoning is faulted. Can you tell me why it is so.
A general goal would be, "Get in shape." But a specific goal would say, "Join a health club and work out 3 days a week."
I have difficulty understanding the correctness of the placements of commas for the sentences like the ones above. I happen to think those in quotes are like a noun or its equivalent and see no valid reason to have commas as they did.
A general goal would be this. But a specific goal would say this.
I think my reasoning is not sound (or faulted) in that it seems a known practice to write like this (with a comma before a quote):
John would say, "He would delivered the pizza as soon as possible."
Top answer
Hi, It's certainly common practice. But I wouldn't go so far as to say it's incorrect without a comma. I'd say the use of the comma reflects the fact that, in speech, most people would naturally pause before uttering the quotation.
- Hi, It's certainly common practice.
- But I wouldn't go so far as to say it's incorrect without a comma.
- I'd say the use of the comma reflects the fact that, in speech, most people would naturally pause before uttering the quotation.
- Best wishes, Clive
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
1 Answers
0
Hi,
It's certainly common practice. But I wouldn't go so far as to say it's incorrect without a comma.
I'd say the use of the comma reflects the fact that, in speech, most people would naturally pause before uttering the quotation.
Best wishes, Clive
It's certainly common practice. But I wouldn't go so far as to say it's incorrect without a comma.
I'd say the use of the comma reflects the fact that, in speech, most people would naturally pause before uttering the quotation.
Best wishes, Clive
0
Related Questions