0
Park sang joon Posted 12 years ago
Grammar

A perfect participle phrase.

I didn't want to ask this question again here because Mr.Jim explained a perfect participle phrase already to me, but I didn't understand, I'm such a fool, that usage completely, so I am asking for your help though it might be considered as being shameful.

1.My dog having nearly died, he revived it.
2.With my dog having nearly died, he revived it.
3.When my dog having nearly died, he revived it.

In the above sentence, I don't know why only #3 is ungrammatical.
When we use a perfect participle phrase, is there restriction on using with a conjunction?
  

Top answer

park sang joon In the above sentence, I don't know why only #3 is ungrammatical It's really hard to deal with your question when all 3 sentences are unnatural and non-native. I wouldn't call any of them grammatically correct. My dog nearly died, but he revived it.

— Mister Micawber

  • park sang joon In the above sentence, I don't know why only #3 is ungrammatical It's really hard to deal with your question when all 3 sentences are unnatural and non-native.
  • I wouldn't call any of them grammatically correct.
  • My dog nearly died, but he revived it.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
park sang joonIn the above sentence, I don't know why only #3 is ungrammatical
It's really hard to deal with your question when all 3 sentences are unnatural and non-native. I wouldn't call any of them grammatically correct.

My dog nearly died, but he revived it.
0
0
Thank you, Mr.Micawber, for your answer.Emotion: smile
I have just used the perfect participle phrases; that's all; What is the problem at all
0
0
park sang joon What is the problem at all?
None of those is at all natural or native.
0

Related Questions