A or the

Question

Hi, I am reading a book. This scene is taking place in a kitchen. The narrator described:

"He was carrying dishes from a wall cupboard to a laid dining table".

I think the indefinite article was picked by the author because while you can expect a dining table in a kitchen, you don't necessarily expect it to be laid, so because its state of being laid is mentioned for the first time, "a" is used. But would it be wrong to use "the" right of the bat? There's only table and perhaps it's always laid, so it's a permanent thing. Does that make sense?

Mister Micawber · Accepted Answer

AnonymousI think the indefinite article was picked by the author because while you can expect a dining table in a kitchen, you don't necessarily expect it to be laid, so because its state of being laid is mentioned for the first time, "a" is used.

That is a promising analysis.

AnonymousBut would it be wrong to use "the" right of the bat? There's only table and perhaps it's always laid, so it's a permanent thing. Does that make sense?

Yes, that makes sense.

Personally, I think the author chose 'a' to give the table a subtle sense of newness (i.e., previously unknown) for the reader.

A or the

Top answer

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

Related Questions