0
Deepak chop Posted 10 years ago
Grammar

A light or the light?

My dear teachers,

I am walking with a friend in a park at night and suddenly I see a light. I turn to my friend and say to him:
"My friend! Do you see a light?"
"My friend! Do you see the light?"

Either is right, yes? "The" just makes it more definite (THAT light)?

Thank you
  

Top answer

Yes, either. But most natural is '. .

  • Yes, either.
  • But most natural is '.
  • .
  • '.
  • In English culture, we do not usually address our friends as 'my friend' in a context like this.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
Yes, either. But most natural is '. . . that light...'.

In English culture, we do not usually address our friends as 'my friend' in a context like this.
0
CliveYes, either. But most natural is '. . . that light...'.
Thank you very much.
CliveIn English culture, we do not usually address our friends as 'my friend' in a context like this.
Thank you for that, I shall be mindful of that in the future!
0
deepak chopDo you see the light?"
I ask my friend if he can see the same light I am looking at.
deepak chopDo you see a light?"
1. I am testing my friend's ability to see as well as I do. I question if I'm really seeing a light. Am I imagining something?

2. I am preparing to ask him what the source of the light is

Related Questions