0
Olga55 Posted 17 years ago
Grammar

A gerund or a participle?

Hi! In this sentence: Being chosen as an astronaut identifies one as capable and commited.

Is Being chosen a gerund or a participle? And what part of speech is this?

I think it's a gerund and is used as a subject in the sentence?

Thank you.
  

Top answer

Hi Olga. Your sentence seems rather odd. "Being chosen as an astronaut , he has been identified as capable and committed " seems like Participle Clause, where participle is a predicate.

  • Hi Olga.
  • Your sentence seems rather odd.
  • "Being chosen as an astronaut , he has been identified as capable and committed " seems like Participle Clause, where participle is a predicate.
  • But in your one there is no subject in subordinate clause.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

11 Answers
0
Hi Olga. Your sentence seems rather odd. "Being chosen as an astronaut, he has been identified as capable and committed " seems like Participle Clause, where participle is a predicate. But in your one there is no subject in subordinate clause.
0
Hi,
You're right.

You can check that it's a gerund by seeing if you can substitute a noun,
eg Can I say 'Experience as an astronaut identifies one as capable and commited'? Yes, I can! So, 'being chosen' must be a gerund.

Best wishes, Clive
0
hi can you help me pls
0
Oops... Thank you, Clive. Emotion: smile But if I say in my way, would it be defined as participle clause?
0
hi clive can u help me pls
0
Anonymoushi can you help me pls

What sort of help do you need? Why don't you start a new thread with your quesiton?

Fandorin, yes, that was a participle. Having been chosen, he..
0
Hi,
"Being chosen as an astronaut, he has been identified as capable and committed "

But if I say in my way, would it be defined as participle clause?

Yes, the participle is used adjectivally to describe 'he'.

In the grammar terms that I use, I'd call it a participle phrase and not a participle clause.

Bbest wishes, Clive
0
Hi, Barbara. Thank you. Thank you, Clive.
0
hi clive ineed your help
pls
0
hi grammar geek can u write aletter 2 me for my emploer asking 4 holidays pls thanku very much

Related Questions