0
Victo Posted 13 years ago
Grammar

'a friend of Mike' or 'a friend of Mike's'

Grammatically speaking, which one is correct, #1 or #2?

1. He is a friend of Mike.
2. He is a friend of Mike's.

Thank you.
  

Top answer

number 1 is correct... :-)

  • number 1 is correct...
  • :-)
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

26 Answers
0
number 1 is correct... :-)
0
Both are correct, but the second is more idiomatic, as you already know.
0
If this is a repeat question, my bad. I'm on my fifth rye and ginger. I'll have two for you, Aspara Gus.
0
victoIf this is a repeat question, my bad.
Oh, no, I said as you already know because you’re a native speaker.
victoI'm on my fifth rye and ginger. I'll have two for you, Aspara Gus.
I’d better not tonight. Next time!
0
in sentence of number2 --- he is friend of mike's …. "friend of" is a possession telling that is mike's friend then why do we need use another possession mike's in the end of sentence?!....
0
aicahcutewhy do we need to use another possessive at the end of sentence?
It’s not grammatically necessary; it’s just idiomatic. The double possessive should probably be avoided in formal writing, however.
0
So in formal writing, you'd use this?

He is a friend of Mike.
0
victoSo in formal writing, you'd use this?
He is a friend of Mike.
I would aim for something a bit more natural, like He is Mike’s friend or He is one of Mike’s friends.
0
But without a recast, which is more acceptable in formal writing—a friend of Mike or Mike's?
0
I’d have to say the former.

Related Questions