0
Danny154 Posted 14 years ago
Grammar

A few short questions

Which, if any, is incorrect (or less good, in your opinion, for any reason):

1.
A. The clock is still broken.
B. The clock is broken still.

2.
A. She is as sharp as ever.
B. She is sharp as ever.

3.
A. A man with a frightening demeanor.
B. A man of a frightening demeanor.

4.
A. The sound of trains passing by has been the background of much of my life.
B. The sound of trains passing by has been a background for much of my life.

5.
A. I was away on the night of the murder.
B. I was away the night of the murder.

6.
A. I don't shy away from public attention.
B: I don't shy from public attention.

Also,

7. In conservative cultures, a young woman is wedded to \ with a certain man regardless of her feelings.


Thank you!
  

Top answer

1A: Correct. 1B: Less good 2A: Correct. 2B: Less good 3A: Correct.

  • 1A: Correct.
  • 1B: Less good 2A: Correct.
  • 2B: Less good 3A: Correct.
  • 3B: Less good, probably incorrect 4A: Much less good.
  • 4B: Correct.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
1A: Correct. 1B: Less good
2A: Correct. 2B: Less good
3A: Correct. 3B: Less good, probably incorrect
4A: Much less good. 4B: Correct.
5A: Correct. 5B: Less good
6A: Correct. 6B: Much less good
7: "In conservative cultures, a young woman is wedded TO a certain man regardless of her feelings" is correct, but a native English speaker would say: "In conservative
0
Thank you.

How critically inferior is 2B to 2A ("broken still" vs. "still broken")?
If the text is a bit dramatic or poetic, and if "broken still" gives it better rhythm, might it not be preferable?
0
A. “The clock is still broken” would definitely be used by a native English speaker and is 100% correct.
B. “The clock is broken still” is about 80% correct, but is perfectly understandable. Certainly, this phrase could used in a poetic context (particularly to assist rhyming), but not in a dramatic context, in my opinion.
0
ArchieWW1A: Correct. 1B: Less good
I agree.
ArchieWW2A: Correct. 2B: Less good
I think 2B is fine.
ArchieWW3A: Correct. 3B: Less good, probably incorrect
I think 3A is acceptable and 3B is unnatural. For me, the most natural would be 'A man of frightening demeanor'.
0
Thank you.

So just to make sure - "A man of frightening demeanor" is correct and natural?
0
Danny154So just to make sure - "A man of frightening demeanor" is correct and natural?
Correct grammatically, and natural in a poem or as a literary flourish, but hardly the kind of thing we'd say to describe our boss or assistant principal.

Related Questions