0
Navitasan Posted 4 years ago
Grammar

A cousin/one of his cousins/someone

Which are correct:


1) Tom doesn't know if one of his cousins talks behind his back, so when that cousin is around, Tom is very careful about what he says.


2) Tom doesn't know if a cousin talks behind his back, so when that cousin is around, Tom is very careful about what he says.


3) Tom doesn't know if somebody talks behind his back, so when that person is around, Tom is very careful about what he says.


I think '1' works and '3' doesn't ('somebody' cannot be somebody specific. It is general.)


I have greater doubts about '2'. I think within this context it would be understandable, but 'a cousin' seems general.


Gratefully,

Navi

  

Top answer

navitasan I think '1' works and '3' doesn't ('somebody' cannot be somebody specific. ) Yes, '1' works. 3) Tom doesn't know if somebody anybody talks behind his back, so when that person is around, so when people are around, Tom is very careful about what he says.

  • navitasan I think '1' works and '3' doesn't ('somebody' cannot be somebody specific.
  • ) Yes, '1' works.
  • 3) Tom doesn't know if somebody anybody talks behind his back, so when that person is around, so when people are around, Tom is very careful about what he says.
  • Yes, '3' is general, but even if you want it to be general, write it as shown above.
  • Whether you leave it as originally written, or you change it as above, it doesn't have the same meaning as 1).
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
navitasanI think '1' works and '3' doesn't ('somebody' cannot be somebody specific. It is general.) Yes, '1' works.
3) Tom doesn't know if somebody anybody talks behind his back, so when that person is around,

Related Questions