0
Anonymous Posted 4 years ago
Grammar

A brave officer

"Over 17 defiant pages, Arredondo is not a fumbling school police chief who a damning state investigation blamed for not taking command and wasted time by looking for keys to a likely unlocked door, but a brave officer whose level-headed decisions saved the lives of other students."

From the Associated Press.

Does "a brave officer" mean "Arredondo" in the clause but a brave officer whose level-headed decisions saved the lives of other students?

  

Top answer

anonymous Does "a brave officer" mean "Arredondo" in the clause but a brave officer whose level-headed decisions saved the lives of other students? Yes. The formula is "not X but Y".

  • anonymous Does "a brave officer" mean "Arredondo" in the clause but a brave officer whose level-headed decisions saved the lives of other students?
  • Yes.
  • The formula is "not X but Y".
  • I would like to have seen a companion comma after "chief", making the enclosed phrase parenthetical.
  • The comma after "door" is not needed otherwise, but I suppose it serves to break up a too-long sentence.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
anonymousDoes "a brave officer" mean "Arredondo" in the clause but a brave officer whose level-headed decisions saved the lives of other students?

Yes. The formula is "not X but Y". I would like to have seen a companion comma after "chief", making the enclosed phrase parenthetical. The comma after "door" is not needed otherwise, but I suppose it serves to b

Related Questions