0
Navitasan Posted 8 years ago
Grammar

A box full of cookies

1) Twice, I took a box full of cookies to his office.

2) I took a box full of cookies twice to his office.

3) I took a box full of cookies to his office twice.


Which of the above work?

It seems to me that '2' and '3' are saying that I took the same box to his office both times! Am I correct?


Gratefully,

Navi

  

Top answer

#3 sounds most natural to me, and #1 is OK if you want to emphasize 'twice'. #2 sounds a little awkward to me. I think the meaning about taking the same box twice would not naturally occur to a native speaker.

  • #3 sounds most natural to me, and #1 is OK if you want to emphasize 'twice'.
  • #2 sounds a little awkward to me.
  • I think the meaning about taking the same box twice would not naturally occur to a native speaker.
  • One would typically say it differently, eg I took the same box of cookies to his office twice.
  • Anyway, the context will usually make the intended meaning clear.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

#3 sounds most natural to me, and #1 is OK if you want to emphasize 'twice'. #2 sounds a little awkward to me.

I think the meaning about taking the same box twice would not naturally occur to a native speaker. One would typically say it differently, eg I took the same box of cookies to his office twice.

Anyway, the context will usually make the intended meaning clear.

Related Questions