0
Stephenlearner Posted 7 years ago
Grammar

A book which gives you

Hello,


In the following sentence, if I add a comma before "which", does it make a difference ?


A dictionary is a book which gives you the meanings of words.

A dictionary is a book, which gives you the meanings of words.


Thank you very much.

  

Top answer

stephenlearner ... does it make a difference? Yes, the difference is that it would be wrong!

  • stephenlearner ...
  • does it make a difference?
  • Yes, the difference is that it would be wrong!
  • The relative clause is clearly a defining (restrictive) one, so no comma is required.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
stephenlearner

... does it make a difference?


Yes, the difference is that it would be wrong!

The relative clause is clearly a defining (restrictive) one, so no comma is required.

0
stephenlearnerIn the following sentence, if I add a comma before "which", does it make a difference ?

It is incorrect with a comma.
Here the comma is optional.

A dictionary is a book with word definitions, which sometimes includes an appendix giving the history of the language.

Related Questions