A book is on the table
A: "A book is on the table. Bring it to me."
B: "Look! A frog is on the table. Catch it. Be quick!"
A sounds a bit unnatural, but B sounds good to me.
I think "A noun is on the X" is usually used when the speaker finds something unexpected. If so, in A "a book" isn't an unexpected thing, and A isn't a normal way of stating, I think. Am I right?
Top answer
I don't know how you're reasoning this through, and I don't completely understand why the contrast between expected and unexpected should make a big difference, but for me, both should have an existential- there construction. There's a [book / frog] on the table. and so on.
- I don't know how you're reasoning this through, and I don't completely understand why the contrast between expected and unexpected should make a big difference, but for me, both should have an existential- there construction.
- There's a [book / frog] on the table.
- and so on.
- CJ
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
I don't know how you're reasoning this through, and I don't completely understand why the contrast between expected and unexpected should make a big difference, but for me, both should have an existential-there construction.
There's a [book / frog] on the table. ... and so on.
CJ
0
Related Questions