0
Wowenglish Posted 16 years ago
Grammar

2 questions

StartFragment>

I have two questions.

A. I wonder if there is any difference between "1" and "2".

1. He is a boy growing up on New Zealand's East Coast in the 1900's.

2. He was a boy growing up on New Zealand's East Coast in the 1900's.

B. I wonder if the next two sentences have the same meaning.

He is a boy growing up on New Zealand's East Coast in the 1900's.

He is a boy who grew up on New Zealand's East Coast in the 1900's.
  

Top answer

A1: Use this to set the scene for a story that is sent in that time and place. It would work as in introduction to this story. A2: use to in normal text to refer to someone who did something important while he was a boy that long ago, or the fact that he was a boy at that time had meaning.

  • A1: Use this to set the scene for a story that is sent in that time and place.
  • It would work as in introduction to this story.
  • A2: use to in normal text to refer to someone who did something important while he was a boy that long ago, or the fact that he was a boy at that time had meaning.
  • B2: Use this to set a scene as well.
  • Since we are long past the early 1900s (Note: No 's), any use of "is a boy" would be for literary reasons.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
A1: Use this to set the scene for a story that is sent in that time and place. It would work as in introduction to this story.
A2: use to in normal text to refer to someone who did something important while he was a boy that long ago, or the fact that he was a boy at that time had meaning.
B2: Use this to set a scene as well.

Since we are long past the early 1900s (Note: No 's)

Related Questions